India yet to make a choice between Gandhi and Godse

This morning when I got up to open my laptop again after an interval of months spent by me in hospitals, medical check-ups etc

Brij Bhardwaj Mar 06, 2020

This morning when I got up to open my laptop again after an interval of months spent by me in hospitals, medical check-ups etc. I was in for a surprise message from old friend and colleague: "Brij. let us go  back to your old city of birth Lahore in Pakistan which we had visited forty years ago" to witness historic  developments then like Pakistan  ruler Gen Zia ul Haq and U.S Ambassador to Pakistan getting  killed in an aircrash of a four-engine plane.

What followed has only shown that some historical facts never change. After   visiting Afghanistan many times, seen tanks running in streets of Kabul, generals changing sides to hang old friends, how many more games are yet to be played! Afghanistan's future remains a guess hard to make. Over the years the number of disturbed areas has increased  and the number of imperial powers hoping to find a solution has not changed.

Over the years, the borders and religion have  continued to divide nations. The allies and friends  have changed. I, for one, witnessed American tanks and planes, used by Pakistan, attacking  India while Russians gave us some weapons of inferior quality.  This  battle  has continued, China has replaced the US as a friend  of  Pakistan  while  President Donald Trump  and Prime Minister  Narendra  Modi have become great friends.

The nations have no permanent friends but have changing interests. There can be a war for the right to sell opium. Only a few understand that peace is the only way out. Mahatma Gandhi chose non-violence to fight the British and many others in the world. The USA  and in other parts of the world joined the battle for civil rights through peaceful means. Use of weapons will always dominate as investment  in weapons is huge while lobby for peace is weak.  

Even in India, the land of Budha and Gandhi, there are many voices who speak for Nathuram Godse, Gandhi's killer, and want to settle the battles on the streets. Nuclear weapons are  too dangerous  to be used, but  less lethal types  are always  available   as it is  easier to shoot  the brave  than to face the bullet. After so many wars and realisation that there will be no winner in a nuclear war, nations large, powerful or weak have not learnt their lessons.    

India may soon complete 70 years of freedom. Problems however remain the same. August 1947, when my family migrated to Delhi from Lahore, there were riots in Delhi and in other parts of the country. Even today there is no peace. The country has yet to make a choice between Mahatama Gandhi and Nathuram Godse.

(The writer is a veteran journalist and commentator. He can be contacted at

Post a Comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.