India: why secrecy over Narendra Modi's coronavirus relief fund damages democracy

Since India overtook Brazil in September to become the country with the second largest number of coronavirus cases in the world (after the US), the response of the government of Narendra Modi has come under even tighter scrutiny

Sep 21, 2020
Vidya Venkat, SOAS, University of London

Since India overtook Brazil in September to become the country with the second largest number of coronavirus cases in the world (after the US), the response of the government of Narendra Modi has come under even tighter scrutiny.

In late March, Prime Minister Modi announced the formation of a special fund to address the emergency situation caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Called the Prime Minister’s Citizen Assistance and Relief in Emergency Situations Fund (PM-CARES Fund), it has attracted controversy right from the start.

According to its official website, the fund was set up to collect donations from India and abroad to “undertake and support relief or assistance of any kind relating to a public health emergency or any other kind of emergency”. The website says the fund will provide financial assistance and grants to affected populations.

But the prime minister’s office has refused to provide exact details of donations made to the fund or make public decisions about how the donations are being used.

Image removed.Screen grab from the official website of the PM-CARES Fund.

Several information seekers, including me, have tried to use India’s Right to Information (RTI) Act, which facilitates access to government files and records, to find out more details about the fund. We have been blocked, with a number of requests for information turned down by Modi’s office on the grounds that the fund is a public charitable trust and not a “public authority” as defined under the RTI act.

Outstanding questions

The fund’s website claims that in the financial year ending March 2020, 20 billion rupees (£210 million) was spent on supplying 50,000 ventilators manufactured by Indian firms to government hospitals. It also says that 10 billion rupees was given to state governments to assist migrant labourers, and that another 1 billion rupees was allocated to support COVID-19 vaccine development efforts.

But when the transparency activist Anjali Bhardwaj sent an RTI request to the ministry of health about the ventilators, the response showed that only 17,100 were eventually allocated or dispatched to states and union territories by July 20. Bhardwaj’s response also revealed that two of the firms received funding even though they hadn’t been recommended by a technical committee.

So far, it’s also been impossible to verify through RTI queries what other money was spent giving assistance to migrant labourers, or which of India’s 25 vaccine development initiatives the PM-CARES fund has supported.

In late August, Modi’s office announced the fund would finance two 500-bed hospitals in Bihar. But this has further fuelled controversy, with the announcement seen by some opposition figures as a political move ahead of assembly elections due in the state in October given that other states have higher numbers of cases.

And in September, the Supreme Court struck down a petition demanding that money from the fund be transferred to the National Disaster Response Fund to finance COVID-19 relief work.

Government secrecy

The union minister, Ravi Shankar Prasad, has hit out at political opponents who were demanding accountability for the PM-CARES Fund. While he claimed that “transparency was writ large” in the way the fund functions, it’s curious that the prime minister’s office continues to block legitimate queries about it.

In late August, I filed an RTI application seeking various details of the charitable trust under which the PM-CARES Fund had been registered, and which state regulatory authority was monitoring the trust. But I was refused information on the grounds that the fund was not a public authority.

However, this assertion does not pass muster. Back in 2007, a similar situation arose with regards to a request for information about the Prime Minister’s National Relief Fund (PMNRF), which has received public contributions since it was set up in 1948 by India’s first prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru. The Central Information Commission, which adjudicates information appeals, made it clear that the prime minister’s office had to comply with requests for information about the PMNRF.

As transparency campaigner Lokesh Batra told me, the entire credibility of the new PM-CARES Fund relies upon Modi making appeals for donations. Its website uses a domain which is reserved for government bodies. The fund is housed in the prime minister’s office and uses its address. Several of Batra’s right for information queries on the fund have also been denied since April.

Politics of transparency

Those holding high office are often reluctant to be transparent about government affairs, fearing political consequences. During my PhD fieldwork on the right to information movement in India, I’ve been observing how information received under the act influences public perception about government performance. This information can be used by political opponents to delegitimise those in power. Such competitive politics, however, helps to deepen democracy and keep the misuse of power in check.

When Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) won a majority in India’s 2014 election, it was helped by the previous Congress coalition falling prey to two major corruption scandals. Both these scandals, surrounding the allocation of 2G spectrum and the Commonwealth Games, were brought to light through the use of the RTI act.

Now that the heat of public scrutiny is on the current BJP government in the middle of the pandemic, it’s their turn to demonstrate that donations to the PM-CARES Fund are being put to proper use.Image removed.

Vidya Venkat, PhD Candidate in Social Anthropology, SOAS, University of London

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Post a Comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Best stock broker in India
Thu, 06/22/2023 - 11:08
We are called Best Stock Broker in India and largely referred to as agents who are skilled and certified to invest in the securities market. We review the Best Trading Platform in India and act as agents for buyers and sellers of stocks and charge a fee against the delivery of our services.
Wed, 08/02/2023 - 12:56
Hey there! I could have sworn I've been to this site before
but after browsing through some of the post I realized it's new to me.
Anyways, I'm definitely glad I found it and I'll be bookmarking and checking back frequently!
transex lisboa
Wed, 08/16/2023 - 23:50
Way cool! Some extremely valid points! I appreciate you writing
this article and the rest of the site is also really good.
Sun, 08/27/2023 - 06:03
Please let me know if you're looking for a writer for
your blog. You have some really great posts and I think
I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some
of the load off, I'd really like to write some content for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine.
Please send me an e-mail if interested. Thank you!
Sun, 08/27/2023 - 07:12
Sweet blog! I found it while browsing on Yahoo News.
Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
I've been trying for a while but I never seem to get there!
Many thanks
Sample Template
Fri, 08/04/2023 - 09:04
Hi to every one, the contents present at this web page are really awesome
for people experience, well, keep up the good work fellows.
Buy Ambien Fast Shipping
Sun, 08/06/2023 - 04:32
She discovered that the money price with the coupon was solely about $10 -
a lot better than the $46 she would have needed to pay without insurance coverage.
where to buy Zolpidem in the uk
Sun, 08/06/2023 - 06:09
The primary Black graduate of Wellesley College got
here within the yr 1887, and 129 years later President Johnson turned the primary Black
travestis lisboa
Mon, 08/07/2023 - 20:02
You need to be a part of a contest for one of the best blogs online.
I am going to highly recommend this blog!
transex lisboa
Mon, 08/07/2023 - 22:57
This excellent website certainly has all the information and facts I needed about this subject and didn't
know who to ask.
Tue, 08/08/2023 - 03:44
This piece of writing will assist the internet users for
building up new webpage or even a weblog from start
to end.
Thu, 08/17/2023 - 11:51
Quality articles is the crucial to invite the visitors to go to see the website, that's
what this web page is providing.
Sun, 08/27/2023 - 07:12
Sweet blog! I found it while browsing on Yahoo News.
Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
I've been trying for a while but I never seem to get there!
Many thanks
Fri, 09/22/2023 - 03:07
So there we have it, GSA seach engine ranker really has come a long way the past yrar andd
has been updated nearly every single day wkth book fixes, minor features and major features.
more info
Thu, 10/26/2023 - 20:46
Freelancers can bid for long or brief-term projects and give a fixed price tag for each
and every project.
Wed, 11/01/2023 - 17:23
Great job on this post! The content is incredibly educational and well-researched, providing valuable insights into the subject at hand.
The way of writing is compelling and progresses smoothly, making it an pleasurable read.
I admire the effort put into communicating complex ideas in a
clear and manner. This post has certainly
expanded my knowledge on the subject. Well done to the writer for
delivering such a high-quality piece!|I'm thoroughly impressed with the high quality of this
write-up. The writer has skillfully presented a fair view on the topic, providing both sides
of the argument in a fair and unbiased manner. The investigation and facts cited throughout
the piece add credibility to the points made. I value the lucidity of the writing, which made it simple to comprehend and understand intricate ideas.
This write-up is a valuable asset for anyone seeking a thorough
understanding of the topic.|This article is a breath of fresh air!
The author's unique perspective and innovative approach make it set itself
apart from the rest. I found myself captivated in the compelling storytelling and the effortless flow of ideas.
The author's passion for the topic shines through every word, making the reading experience truly pleasurable.

I commend the effort put into fashioning such an unique piece.

Well done!|This is an remarkable piece of work! The author's comprehensive knowledge of the topic is
evident throughout the piece. The clear-cut and
succinct explanations, paired with supporting examples, make complex ideas easy to comprehend.

I appreciate the extensive study that went into this article, as it provides a solid groundwork for the points
presented. The author's style of writing is captivating and keeps the audience hooked until the conclusion. I
was astounded by the flawless transition between thoughts and the rational structure of the piece.
The author's ability to present subtle arguments and
provide thought-provoking observations is admirable.
It's clear that a great deal of energy and expertise went into
creating this outstanding write-up. I strongly recommend
it to anyone looking for a expertly executed and illuminating article.|I must say, this article went beyond my anticipations!
The comprehensiveness of examination and the unique point of view presented really differentiates
it apart. The writer's command of the subject is evident, making complicated concepts easily
understandable. The writing style is engaging and grabs the reader's attention from the very beginning.
I found myself absorbed in the content, eagerly absorbing every
word. This is a praiseworthy piece of work that deserves
recognition. Well done!
Mon, 12/11/2023 - 11:34
I blog often and I truly appreciate your information. The article
has truly peaked my interest. I will book mark your site and keep checking for
new information about once a week. I opted in for your RSS feed as well.